George Chauncey
Amazon Price: $16.06
List Price: $22.00
Usually ships in 24 hours
By: Basic Books
Amazon Marketplace: 85
new & used starting at $9.24
|
Buy at Amazon.com
|
Browse similar items by category:
Subjects -> Gay & Lesbian -> History
Subjects -> Gay & Lesbian -> Nonfiction -> General
Subjects -> Gay & Lesbian -> Nonfiction -> General AAS
Customer Reviews:
Total reviews: 14
Average rating: 4.5 of 5
A treasure chest of forgotten lore 4 out of 5 stars.
11 of 12 people found this review helpful.
This book was preceded in my conciousness by high critical praise and so I approached it with great expectations. And in great part it met these expectations.More than anything else, this is a work of love, being the excavation of forgotten facts in the history of gay life as it was lived by decades of gay men, experiences now mostly forgotten or scattered in obscure and fading documents. It is an extraordinary work of social archeology, resurrecting a world I never knew exisited. And Chauncey does this in exceptional detail, using clear prose, so that by the end the geography of this world has been salvaged and reconstructed, like Combray from Marcel's teacup.
As the book proceeds, the writing becomes stronger, particularly as the facts become more readily available, and the arguments and conclusions become more convincing. The last chapter is especially good on the submergence of gay life after Prohibition. This book is clearly one of the masterpieces of gay history, on par with John Boswell's work especially in it's dependence on primary sources.
The only criticism I have lies in the fact that Chauncey often has trouble shaping his information and often can't create a forest out of the trees. Especially in the earlier chapters, he often fails to make a summary statement without such a host of qualifiers that you wonder why he bothers in the first place. And as a previous reviewer has noted, there are alot of repetitions that a good editor should have corrected.
Despite all these reservations, for those interested in discovering a lost world, this book will be a revelation.
Editorial Review:
Winner of the 1994 Los Angeles Times Book Prize for History, this brilliant work challenges the conventional wisdom that before the 1960s gay life existed only in the closet.