Leah Moore, John Reppion
Amazon Price: $15.99
List Price: $19.99
Usually ships in 24 hours
By: Wildstorm
Amazon Marketplace: 29
new & used starting at $2.90
|
Buy at Amazon.com
|
Browse similar items by category:
Subjects -> Comics & Graphic Novels -> Comic Strips -> General
Subjects -> Comics & Graphic Novels -> Comic Strips -> General AAS
Subjects -> Comics & Graphic Novels -> Graphic Novels -> Fantasy
Customer Reviews:
Total reviews: 3
Average rating: 4.5 of 5
AMAZING ALBION 5 out of 5 stars.
1 of 2 people found this review helpful.
WOW what a book, the main story is excellent and incorporates characters from some old english comics.This edition has some excerpts from the original comics this book was based on, a trip down memory lane. well worth buying
Why did DC even bother? 3 out of 5 stars.
0 of 0 people found this review helpful.
I was thrilled when I heard back in 2004 that DC would be taking on the IPC characters from British comics. While I had never read any of their original adventures, I was familiar with their thinly-disguised versions in Paul Grist's excellent JACK STAFF series. As a result, I had a soft spot for the Spider, the Steel Claw, Robot Archie, and others, and I was very happy hearing that they would be in the extremely capable hands of comics superstar Alan Moore. Alas, that's not quite what DC gave us. While Moore did help to develop the plot, his daughter Leah and her husband John Reppion are the actual writers, and I feel that they aren't up to his level of craft.
The story involves a mystery behind various British comics heroes and villains: that their "fictional" adventures are true, being based on people whose existence has been erased from the public consciousness. It has the feel of a Silver Age DC Earth-one adventure, in that actual British writers and artists are incorporated into the story, acknowledging that these characters are real. I'm a sucker for storytelling that blurs the line between fantasy and reality, so this worked very well for me; however, there are too many problems that kept me from enjoying it overall. A big issue I have with this story is the lack of references as to who these characters are. As DC is an American comic publisher, it would seem logical that a large amount of effort would need to be put into character development in order for the story to appeal and/or make sense to American readers. Well, you won't find it here, nor is much provided in the selection of classic reprints that make up the final section of the book. L. Moore and Reppion take too much for granted, so readers are left on their own to figure out who these characters are and what the references mean. Honestly, I had done quite a bit of research on them prior to reading this book, and even I had a difficult time with it. But even worse is that the events in the story are just too convenient - how could such a massive conspiracy be solved so easily? Shane Oakley's art is too cartoonish, and it's difficult to tell who is who, at times. In fact, comparing it to the beautiful artwork in the classic reprints, it's really a shame that a more capable artist wasn't used.
In closing, this book was a letdown. It amazes me that DC would take the time to work out a deal with IPC and then handle these characters so poorly. If you want to see them handled properly, check out the aforementioned JACK STAFF series - the whole thing is quite good! In addition, Titan Books currently has some of their original adventures in print: KING OF CROOKS/THE SPIDER, THE STEEL CLAW, and ALBION ORIGINS (includes Kelly's Eye, Dolmann, Janus Stark, and Cursitor Doom). These oversize hardcovers are available through Amazon UK.