John Maddox Roberts
List Price: $5.99
By: Wizards of the Coast
Amazon Marketplace: 8
new & used starting at $10.62
|
Buy at Amazon.com
|
Browse similar items by category:
Subjects -> Entertainment -> Puzzles & Games -> Role Playing & Fantasy -> General
Subjects -> Entertainment -> Puzzles & Games -> Role Playing & Fantasy -> General AAS
Subjects -> Science Fiction & Fantasy -> Authors, A-Z -> ( R ) -> Roberts, John Maddox
Customer Reviews:
Total reviews: 7
Average rating: 3.5 of 5
Great story, but the ending dissapoints. 3 out of 5 stars.
11 of 12 people found this review helpful.
Roberts has created some vibrant characters in this mystery about three misfit's given the responsiblity to solve a murder in the midst of a near-siege of Tarsis. The personal history surrounding Ironwood, the mercenary, and Stunbog, the former mage, is especially rich. The book leaves the reader guessing at the identity of the murderer all the way to the very end of the novel. And this is where I felt the book failed. A good mystery novel should present all the clues and motives needed to solve the crime before it reaches the last few pages. 'Murder in Halruha' and 'Murder in Cormyr' serve as very good examples of this. But 'Murder in Tarsis' dissapoints, because it presents key clues and most importantly the murderer's motive at the very end of the novel. The reader never has a chance to deduce who the killer is or why he/she did it. That's why someone will read mystery novels versus other type of novels after all. Because they want to test their powers of deduction. This book never gives the reader the oppurtunity to do so. An even better mystery novel will redirect or mislead the reader subtlely to suspect other characters of being the culprit. But without any real clues, save at the ending of the novel, the reader doesn't even know who to suspect in this story. The ending also lacked the excitement many have come to associate with suspense stories. Roberts has a good writing style and he knows how to create interesting characters, but his ability to create mystery novels is sorely lacking. If you are looking for a good fantasy mystery novel I highly suggest either 'Murder in Halruha' or 'Murder in Cormyr". Better yet, read them both.
Editorial Review:
Who killed Ambassador Bloodarrow?
When the Lord of Tarsis finds himself with a politically volatile murder on his hands, he turns to the three most expendable inhabitants of the city of a solution. A mercenary, a poet-assassin, and a thief might not be everyone's first choice for detectives. But they find they're quite good at bringing murderers to justice.
Perhaps a little too good . . .